This post may contain affiliate links. Please see our disclosure policy.

I am at it again sharing my absolute favorite, go-to Sugar Cookie recipe on Reese Witherspoonโ€™s Draper James Blog! If yโ€™all have not tried my favorite Sugar Cookie recipe yet, itโ€™s an absolute must! ;) I know I regularly mention these cookies to you guys, but this recipe is an absolute keeper! Itโ€™s the ONLY Sugar Cookie that will hold its shape and not break when transporting. Iโ€™m telling you right now, itโ€™ll be love at first bake!

A plate of four heart-shaped cookies with pink and white checkered icing. The plate is on a white napkin on a light wooden table. In the background, there are fresh eggs, a glass jar, and a bottle of milk.

So the truth is, I have been using this recipe for the past 12 years and it has yet to fail me! I tried several different variations, but none are quite as heavenly sweet as this recipe. The secret is the hints of almond extract. Iโ€™m definitely a little biased because I may or may not be a bit of an almond addict (hide your bear claws and almond paste), but trust me! The almond seriously gives the cookies the most amazing taste.

A woman with long, wavy hair sits on a cream sofa. She is wearing a navy shirt with white hearts, white pants, and light pink shoes. A small white table with a decorative pineapple is beside her. A pink blanket is draped over the sofa.

Have you guys seen the new Draper James Valentineโ€™s line? Itโ€™s too cute! I couldnโ€™t resist this pinkish peach gingham jewelry dish and blue and white heart pattern shirt. The material is so cozy and with a feel of high end quality!! I could easily sleep in this shirt. Who wants to have a slumber party? ;)

Heart-shaped dish with pink checkered pattern and Hello Beautiful text, containing small gold earrings. Accompanied by a pink rose and a fringed pink fabric on a light surface.

Okay so back to cookie talk! Once I cracked the code for these Sugar Cookies, they quickly became a family tradition. I even used this recipe for Charlieโ€™s baby shower cookies. When I was planning, I knew I needed a simple recipe that I could easily make in large quantities that all of my guests could enjoy. What better option than some tasty Sugar Cookies? Plus I swear these cookies never lose their shape when baking! Just another reason to whip out a batch for any event or party!

A person with long wavy hair holds a heart-shaped cookie with pink and white checks. The person wears a navy shirt with white hearts and smiles gently. The background is light and blurred.

I canโ€™t help myself and bake these cookies year-roundโ€ฆ Seriously, one year I baked them and my mom and I snuck these exact cookies into the movie theatre. Theyโ€™re THAT good! ;) You truly donโ€™t need a holiday to bust out this recipe. But I do look most forward to making them around Valentineโ€™s Day! I know plenty of people are firm believers in Red Velvet EVERYTHING for the 14th, but Sugar Cookies trump Red Velvet every time in my book ;) Plus, who needs all of that red dye, right?! ;)ย Of course you can snack on them just the way they are, but you can also get so creative with Sugar Cookies!ย I think itโ€™s the versatility of Sugar Cookies that makes them a perfect pairing for Valentineโ€™s Day.

A white plate with three heart-shaped cookies decorated with pink and white checkered icing, placed on a white cloth. Nearby are a wooden spoon and a bowl of four white eggs, all on a white wooden surface.

Every year I love making a ton of these cookies and assembling little bags for our team, friends, and family members. Itโ€™s such an easy and inexpensive gift, but still a great way to show them some love. You can cut a few of the cookies into different sized hearts, play with a combination of pink, white, and red frosting, and of course pile on the sprinkles! ;) No matter what, you end up with a tasty treat for Valentineโ€™s Day!

A person with long hair holds a heart-shaped dish with a pink and white checkered pattern, displaying the text Hello Beautiful. They wear a navy shirt with white heart patterns.

If weโ€™re being honest here, my Valentineโ€™s Day celebrating doesnโ€™t exactly end with my Sugar Cookie marathon. If anything, thatโ€™s only where it starts! I was actually just confessing to being a Valentineโ€™s Day fanatic in a recent interview with Draper James. You should totally read the full interview to hear just how crazy I get with the holiday, but I canโ€™t help myself!

Woman sitting on a white couch holding a pink heart-shaped object, wearing a blue shirt with white heart patterns and white pants. A snake plant is beside her. A soft pink blanket and white bowl are on the couch. She is smiling at the camera.
Now that Iโ€™ve admitted to all of my holiday craziness, what are some of your favorite Valentineโ€™s Day traditions? I canโ€™t wait to hear how you all share the love with the people you care about and I really canโ€™t wait to hear about all the different ways you guys use and decorate these Sugar Cookies!ย Happy baking and Happy Valentineโ€™s Day!

About Melissa Johnson

My bakery experience taught me the secrets to simple baking. Now, I share easy-to-follow recipes and party ideas through Best Friends For Frostingยฎ and my cookbook, Celebrating Everyday, simplifying everyday cooking and holiday celebrations.

You May Also Like

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

4 Comments

  1. Stacy says:

    Hey Melissa! This is great- Iโ€™ve been looking for an amazing sugar cookie recipe! And these gingham cookies are tooo cute. You mentioned the difference in these cookies is the tiny hint of almond flavor. On the post on Reeseโ€™s blog I didnโ€™t see almond extract listed as an ingredient. Can you confirm if it should be included? Sorry if I missed it! Thanks! :)

  2. jill says:

    How did you create the gingham effect on the cookies?

  3. Indya | The Small Adventurer says:

    These are so beautiful! I adore gingham, especially if it’s pink. I almost wouldn’t want to eat these, they’re just too pretty ????

    Indya || The Small Adventurer

    1. Melissa | Best Friends for Frosting says:

      Thank you so much Indya! I am obsessed with Gingham these days! ;)